The controversy surrounding Backyard Social, a venture by Mat Baum and John Mann, has sparked intense debate among residents and officials. Set on a 10-acre site near Interstate 75, the project seeks to introduce a unique blend of live entertainment and outdoor dining, challenging existing zoning regulations. Despite facing opposition from some neighbors, Baum remains confident that his vision will transform the area into a vibrant hub for social activities.

Empowering Community Growth Through Innovative Dining and Entertainment

Understanding the Special Exception Request

The heart of the debate lies in the special exception sought by Backyard Social. According to Sarasota County’s Unified Development Code, establishments can typically operate until 2 a.m., but additional permissions are required for live entertainment past 10 p.m. and outdoor dining. This has led to confusion among residents, who fear potential disturbances. However, Baum clarifies that the primary purpose of the exception is to enhance the experience with live performances and open-air dining.Sarasota County Planning and Development Services confirmed Baum's claims, noting a critical aspect of the design. The innovative use of food trucks parked adjacent to the building, combined with large bay doors, creates an outdoor ambiance. This setup ensures that indoor noise cannot be fully contained, aligning with the county's requirements for outdoor structures.

Addressing Concerns and Seeking Compromise

Despite efforts to address concerns, some commissioners remain skeptical. Just before the January 15 meeting, the request for outdoor entertainment past 10 p.m. was withdrawn, yet this concession did not sway the majority. Commissioners Teresa Mast, Tom Knight, Mark Smith, and Ron Cutsinger expressed reservations, leading to a continuance of the decision. Stanley Morrow, a member of the Waterside Neighborhood Alliance, voiced disappointment over the last-minute changes, emphasizing the broader implications for community life.The alliance presented police reports from Backyard Social's Fort Myers location to highlight potential issues. Incidents ranging from loud behavior to physical altercations were cited as evidence. Jacob Goodwin, a member of the alliance, read excerpts from these reports, underscoring the need for caution. Baum acknowledged initial challenges when the Fort Myers location opened in October 2023, describing the influx of visitors as overwhelming. However, he assured that operations have since stabilized.

Learning from Experience: Comparing Locations

Baum draws a distinction between the Fort Myers and Sarasota locations. The proximity to Florida Gulf Coast University in Fort Myers attracts a late-night college crowd, influencing operating hours. In contrast, the Sarasota location may not necessitate extended hours. Baum cited his experience with Agave Bandido at Waterside Place, where closing times were adjusted based on market demand. Initially closing at 2 a.m., the restaurant now closes at 1 a.m. on weekends. Baum believes similar adjustments could apply to Backyard Social, reflecting the community's needs.

Building Support and Moving Forward

Despite opposition, Backyard Social garners significant support. Developer Pat Neal, impressed by the Fort Myers location, views it as a valuable addition to Lakewood Ranch. Resident A.J. Freda echoed this sentiment, expressing frustration with the lack of local recreational options. When the proposal went before the Planning Commission on November 7, it received a favorable recommendation in a 6-2 vote. Baum aims to reintroduce the proposal in March, focusing on outdoor dining hours to address lingering concerns.

A Vision for the Future

With an investment exceeding million, Baum emphasizes the importance of moving forward without delays. He highlights the brand's popularity, noting that developers frequently seek their involvement in new projects. While understanding the apprehensions of a few, Baum believes the majority supports the initiative. Ultimately, Backyard Social represents more than just a business; it symbolizes a commitment to enhancing community life through innovation and collaboration.